Hello dear
Welcome to Margherita Pizza
At Margherita Pizza, located in the heart of Jamaica, NY, a rich history defines every slice. This iconic spot has been a cherished haven for pizza lovers since the 1980s. With an unwavering commitment to quality, Margherita serves authentic New York-style pizza that captures the hearts of both locals and nostalgic visitors alike. The diverse menu invites you to create your own masterpiece or indulge in classic favorites, from extra cheese to beef pepperoni. Customers rave about the freshness and professionalism evident in every bite. Margherita Pizza is not just a restaurant; it’s a beloved tradition that stands the test of time.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Create Your Own Pizza
Extra Cheese Pizza
Black Olives Pizza
Beef Pepperoni Pizza
About
Margherita Pizza
Welcome to Margherita Pizza: A Culinary Landmark in Jamaica, NY!
Nestled in the heart of Jamaica, New York, Margherita Pizza is more than just a pizzeria; it's a cherished institution that has been serving the community and beyond for decades. Located at 16304 Jamaica Ave, this iconic establishment has locked in the hearts of locals and visitors alike. With a phone number that resonates with nostalgia (+1 718-657-5780), it's easy to see why so many people keep coming back for another slice.
What's on the Menu?
- Create Your Own Pizza: Whether you prefer a classic cheese or want to customize your own masterpiece, Margherita Pizza gives you the freedom to build the perfect pie.
- Extra Cheese Pizza: Ideal for cheese lovers, this option ensures a rich and creamy experience in every bite.
- Specialty Pizzas: From Black Olives to Beef Pepperoni, Broccoli to Spinach, there's something to please every palate.
- Hot Dogs: The menu also features beef hot dogs and sausages, adding a delightful twist for those craving something different.
- Beverages: Pair your meal with energy drinks like Red Bull or Monster—perfect for those looking to recharge.
Why is Margherita Pizza a Must-Visit?
According to loyal customers like Rubin Wilson, who fondly recalls his visits from the '80s, Margherita Pizza hasn't changed, staying true to its roots while consistently delivering authentic New York-style pizza. This sense of nostalgia resonates deeply with many patrons, making each visit feel like a reunion with cherished memories.
Customers have showered praise on the quality of the pizza, with reviews highlighting its status as the best in Jamaica, if not all of New York. Esther Sicard exclaims it’s a “10 to 11 stars” experience, while Waheeda Wazir emphasizes that she wouldn’t dream of ordering pizza from anywhere else. The fresh ingredients and professional service further bolster Margherita Pizza's stellar reputation.
For those returning to NYC, like Daphne Paul, a visit to Margherita Pizza is non-negotiable. It's about more than great food; it's an emotional connection to one's past and a reminder of home. Whether you're indulging in a classic or experimenting with toppings, every slice tells a story of dedication and authenticity.
Conclusion
At Margherita Pizza, the canvas of each pie is a testament to quality and tradition. It's not simply about filling your stomach; it's about reliving joyous moments and creating new memories with every bite. When in Jamaica, NY, make sure to stop by and taste the pizza that has captured hearts for generations!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I’m confident I’m not alone in this sentiment: Margherita Pizza is a cherished gem from my childhood and high school years. At 53, I find myself reminiscing about my visits in the 80s, and I can proudly say that this place has not changed one bit since my first slice. If you grew up in South Queens, you're likely familiar with this iconic spot, and, like me, you probably consider it "your spot." For me, there’s simply no contest—Margherita Pizza reigns supreme. Every time I return to NYC, I absolutely must indulge in a slice or two accompanied by a grape drink. Margherita, please keep doing what you do best. Stay true to your roots, because you’re one of the rare places that serve authentic New York-style pizza. Your dedication to quality is what makes you stand out, and we wouldn't want it any other way! ”
“ The best pizza in Jamaica Queens if not all of new York. Great pizza 10 to 11 stars ”
“ Home town favorite...Truly miss being able to just take the Q111 or 113 buy a few fake shit off the ave lol and enjoy literally quality top of the top pizza.. until I taste what Italy pizza is like but this one here beats any mom and ... ”
“ I would recommend this place more than any pizza shop around , Ny I would never get a pizza from any other but Margherita Pizza they are 10 haven’t tasted any other that’s better than them yet honestly. They are fresh pizzas and professional. ”
“ Always loved Margarita pizza since I was in HS in the early 2000s. Always make sure to visit when I am back in NYC. Some of the best pizza I’ve had in my life. ”
“ I've wanted this pizza since before I left Queens/NY. I came for a visit and I had to eat a slice while I wait for a pie. It tastes just like how I remembered. YUM thank you ”
“ Really good and fresh pizza. The crust is perfect and just how i like it. It’s cooked a little more to give it a bit of crunch and the cheese is so yummy. It’s fresh and hot out the oven and the people seem nice. The mushroom topping is a little weird because it’s like full mushroom pieces not sliced or cut like I’m used to. So it gets a little slimy and interesting. Sausage was authentic but definitely try a cheese slice because it really is just amazing. Price was good though it has gone up but inflation I guess. ”
“ We made the short trip from JFK to try this place out and it lived up to our expectations! Great pizza at a good price! ”